Why Google Pulled Their New Nexus One Cell Phone Off the Market

Google first stuck their toes in the water in the cellbrought to that segment.
phone business with Android on T-Mobile. They wereThen Google jumps in. They are actually very
moderately successful and hoped by involving moresuccessful with Android so far. That's because these
handset makers and networks they would be moredevices are sold the traditional way, in stores, so
successful. So several months ago they jumped in andcustomers who are shopping for smart phones can
made a big splash. Then they introduced their ownsee and touch and try and compare. There is plenty of
phone called the Nexus One. What has happenedroom for Apple and Google and other competitors in
since is very interesting with an important lesson forthat space.
both the company and for us.The Nexus One is none of that. When it was
They upgraded Android and put the new version onintroduced it sounded big, but quickly we started seeing
multiple handsets from various manufacturers likenervous Android partners who were now also
Motorola and HTC. They started working with multiplecompetitors.
networks. They even worked with Verizon to brandWho knows, it could be the best device on the market,
their own version and called it Droid. Things werebut it won't sell because it is only sold on the web.
getting exciting. A little confusing, but we could handleThere are plenty of early adopters there, but that's not
that.how people buy cell phones generally speaking. They
Everyone who worked with Google loved what washave to visit a store and touch the actual device and
happening, until Nexus One. They pulled a fast one andcompare it.
introduced their own handset. At the time I said thatThat's how they buy. They want to compare it to
might be the straw that breaks the camels back.what they already own, to other new devices. They
I said this device might be the best thing since slicedwant to try pressing the keys and see how easy it is
bread, but it may fail for a few very simple reasons.to switch programs.
After only a few months on the market Google justGoogle forgot, or maybe didn't understand that cell
announced they are taking it off the market.phones are not all created equal.
Why was I so sure this would not work?Recommendation. If Google wants to change the
We all remember how Google broke the rules inindustry, or a slice of it, they should get into the
Internet search and won. At the time the Internet waswireless industry with their popular Android. Then after
new, and changing, and they offered the same thingthey build their brand in the space the can begin to
that Yahoo and MSN offered, but faster and better.transform it for their own customers.
Customers were waiting for newer and fasterCurrently Android is selling faster than the iPhone. How
versions.long is the question. When the iPhone was new it sold
Since then they have expanded beyond that traditionalfaster too. At some point sales levels might be the
search engine on the Internet. They have beensame.
successful at all of their efforts, on the net. They areIs Nexus One gone forever? I think Google pulled it off
number one on the net.the market now and may indeed reintroduce it down
Now Google wants to jump into another industry andthe road when their brand is further developed in the
transform it. They want to own wireless going forwardmobile industry.
the same way. The problem is they are not having theThe company has a good attitude. They thought they
same success.would come charging in and transform the wireless
One reason is the cell phone business is not new. Itindustry.
has been around for over 25 years. It has changedWhen they didn't we learned two important things.
and matured in the market along with a couple- One, they won't be successful at everything they
hundred million customers. We are all partners in thistouch, at least not at first try, and
adventure.- Two they pulled this off the market quickly.
The online world was brand new and changing quicklyThat is the sign of a company and group of
when they jumped in. Customers did not have a strongexecutives who may be in tuned enough to actually
idea of what the industry was, as it was quicklymake it in these new businesses.
changing. That was a good marketplace for theThis reminds me of MCI in the 1990's. They too had so
change they brought.many ideas bubbling around. They brought them all to
However the cell phone business is long past thatmarket. Some were successful and others were not.
point.Successes stayed and failures were pulled quickly. No
It is already solid in the mind of the customer. Appleone was scalded. The attitude was right on. Looks like
was successful with the iPhone because the smartwhat we just witnessed with Google.
phone market was already in place and had grown toIt will be interesting to watch their next steps. One
around 15%.more thing. Perhaps when they do bring this back to
People understood smart phones. A segment of thelife, the will give it a name that sounds like a cell phone
marketplace could appreciate the changes Appleinstead of hair conditioner. Just a thought.